Skip to content
Pathway Innovations

Caregivers That Capture Their Kids Crying for Clicks Must Reflect at Themselves

A specific tune has been lingering in my thoughts the past seven days, and it's not, it isn't from the pop star's latest album. It comes by a considerably more refined composer: an educator. The piece is called Big Feelings and its lyrics go: “Big feelings are OK / I’m here to stay with your big feelings.”

The Rise of Strong Emotions On Social Media

Because of the trend for conscious parenting, the concept of “big feelings” has transformed into lucrative online, and generally I welcome that. As a parent, strong emotions are difficult to escape: one is having them, the little one in your home is feeling them and, in one of the largest shifts for us as a species, so are myriad other children on your digital streams.

Indeed, footage of toddlers and children crying is so widespread on some platforms that a lot of parents don't even question it. I don't have TikTok and my Instagram feed is mostly fixated on soup and witchcraft, but when a colleague told me that she thought the phenomenon concerning, not to mention morally dubious, I watched some of the recordings myself.

My Observations: Children at Their Most Fragile

My findings was clip after clip of children at their most exposed. Sobbing, screaming, crying out, and sometimes lashing out physically. I have certainly been observant to these instances in my own house, but watching another person's child going through it feels deeply unsettling, particularly when that child is not receiving solace by their own parent. Least forgivable is a genre of video in which mothers put their children to medical procedures while their baby or toddler cries and screams directly to camera. It should be said that many of the videos are not like that, and yet there is nonetheless something horrible about them all.

In Cases Where Big Feelings Aren't Upsetting

Of course, “big feelings” aren't always wholly upsetting. When your child is lying on the ground heartbroken at the discovery that treats are limited it can be challenging to keep a straight face. Many of us have been told stories of notably unforgettable outbursts of our own. My own included screaming “GIVE ME ALL YOUR MONEY!” in the lobby of the a cultural center in central London. Lightheartedly joking your child about a moment they had a tantrum, or sharing a laugh with your spouse once they have fallen asleep, is acceptable. Capturing a child in a moment of distress and uploading it to the online world for all to see without their consent is a separate issue completely.

Disturbing Practices and Humiliation

Furthermore you have the practices that are plainly concerning, such as a trend that involved startling babies out of crying by flinging a processed food at their faces, or breaking an egg on them. That kind of content appears geared towards shaming children. In a report for the New York Times, a writer commented: “The strangest part of these videos [is that] the parents are scarcely engaging with their kids. Instead they are focused on a online representation of their children that they are sharing online. And they are enjoying their authority over that image.”

The Defense of Education

A number of video makers who would abhor this sort of content. They claim that they are capturing their children at their most exposed not to mock them, but because they are trying to establish educational instances – “see how calmly and effectively I was able to manage this child’s outburst using these strategies”. Several even aim to avoid certain criticism. “This video is published to educate and increase understanding – not for support or opinions”, a particular clip, uploaded by an account run by a medical professional, supposedly reads. The declaration that follows is one of the most self-congratulatory nonsense I have encountered on the internet. “If you don’t live the life, refrain from criticizing the moment.”

A Question of Responsibility

Why not you refrain from sharing the moment? I often wonder. Because I absolutely question these people. The impression I get, when I watch a video of a youngster in distress, whether their parent is performing comfort or not, is a failure of responsibility – the obligation to be present for your child. And I question what signal it conveys, where when your child demonstrates a “big feeling”, you start recording. What does that say to your child about their completely normal emotions? “Sharing real moments is part of the learning”, supposedly.

Considerations on Child Development

When my spouse and I start touring schools for our youngster, it’s challenging not to consider how approaches to child development have evolved since we were children. There is an increased understanding of the fact that “big feelings” are par for the course for youngsters. These days a lot of adults attempt to acknowledge those emotions and give children a secure environment in which to communicate their emotions. However in spite of what the gentle parenting influencers state, I don’t believe you can really provide a safe space for your child if you are capturing their instances of vulnerability and breaching their personal space and integrity in the procedure. If I’m honest, I cannot see these people have much to instruct any of us about child-rearing.

A Closing Question

Certain individuals who will find that extreme, who would object to the fact that in particular aspects I’d rather put a cheese slice on my child's head for a joke than exploit his suffering as a educational instance for engagement. But to them I would say this: if “every action is expression”, what, specifically, are these parents aiming to express?

Written by

Aaron Heath

A wellness coach and writer passionate about holistic health and mindful living, sharing practical advice for personal transformation.

Pathway Innovations

Type to search articles.